What happens after you hand over the email
A buyer messages about something you listed on Marketplace, Craigslist, OfferUp or a small art or craft sale. They agree to your price, sometimes offer extra, and then insist: not your PayPal username, not a payment link, only the email address on your account. The reason changes every time: their bank, their “business account”, their husband pays the bills.
Your email is all they need to send fake PayPal mail to the right inbox. Soon a “payment received” notice arrives, often from an address that only looks like PayPal (one reader spotted “.co.1” at the end). It says the money is pending until you ship the item and send a tracking number, or until you pay to “increase your account limit”. One artist was told to have the buyer transfer $300 to raise the limit and then pay it back.
Some buyers send a real payment from a stolen PayPal account, then ask you to ship to a different address. When the real owner disputes it, the money is taken back and your item is gone.
The giveaways in the chat and the email
“Email only, not your username”
A real buyer can pay you with your username, a link or your email. Insisting on the email alone, with a story about their bank, is the setup.
The money is “pending” until you act
PayPal doesn’t hold a buyer’s payment until you ship or pay a fee. A notice that says it does didn’t come from PayPal.
The sender address is a copy
Hover over or tap the sender. Lookalike addresses, free webmail and odd endings give the fake away.
A new address to ship to
After paying, the buyer wants it sent to a friend, a relative’s store or a different city than the one on the payment.
How Danger Stamp handles it
In Chrome on your computer, Danger Stamp reads Marketplace and Messenger chats: a buyer who won’t pay without your PayPal email gets the conversation stamped. When the fake “payment received” email lands in Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo or another webmail, it stamps that message as well.
How Danger Stamp did in testing
- Examples of this scam caught5 of 6
- Caught by the free version, no AI0 of 6
From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.
Shipped it, or typed your PayPal password?
Do the password step first if you signed in from the email, then deal with the item.
What did you give them?
I shipped the item
- Step 1Do this firstCall the shipping company with the tracking number. Ask them to stop or redirect it.
- Step 2Check your real account yourself, not through their link or email.
- Step 3Report the buyer to the marketplace.
My password
- Step 1Do this firstChange it now on the real site. Type the address yourself.
- Step 2Used it anywhere else? Change it there too.
- Step 3If it was your email password, change that one first.
- Step 4Turn on two-step sign-in.
Other versions of the same scam
The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.
| What it says | What it really is |
|---|---|
| “I sent too much, refund the difference” | The fake email shows a payment above your price, and the buyer asks you to send the extra back by wire, Zelle or gift card. |
| A link to “set up your PayPal to receive” | Instead of a fake notice, the buyer sends a link to create or confirm an account. It’s a copy of PayPal’s sign-in page built to take your password. |
Related scams
Questions
Is it risky to give a buyer my PayPal email?
Your email on its own can’t take money out of your account, but it lets scammers send fake PayPal messages that look personal. If a buyer won’t accept your username or a payment link, treat that as the warning.
How do I check if a PayPal payment is real?
Never use the link or button in the email. Open a new tab, type paypal.com, sign in, and look at your activity. If the payment isn’t listed there, it doesn’t exist.
The email says the money is released once I add a tracking number. Should I ship?
No. That rule doesn’t exist. Shipping first is exactly what they want, and the payment will never show up.
Where do I forward the fake PayPal email?
PayPal takes suspicious emails at phishing@paypal.com. You can also report the buyer on the marketplace and at reportfraud.ftc.gov (US) or antifraudcentre.ca (Canada).
Sources
This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings: