How the “payment on hold” trick plays out
You list something on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist or Kijiji. A buyer agrees to your price fast, often without asking a single question about the item, and says they can’t meet with cash. They’ll pay by Zelle, or their husband, son or cousin will send it and pick it up. They only need your email address.
Minutes later an email arrives that looks like Zelle or PayPal. It says the money is waiting but stuck, because the buyer paid from a “business account” and yours is a standard one. To release it, you must send a few hundred dollars to “upgrade” or “raise your limit”. The buyer then texts a screenshot showing they already paid that fee for you too, and asks you to pay them back.
None of it is real. The email came from the scammers, not the app, and the screenshot is edited. One seller on Reddit was told to send $50 for a Christmas tree plus $500 “to create the account”. Another was told to send $500 more so the full $675 would arrive. Whatever you send goes straight to the buyer, and the item usually never leaves your house.
How to tell the payment notice is fake
You have to pay to get paid
Receiving money never costs the person receiving it. A notice that says your money is held until you send money is the scam itself.
The sender isn’t the app
Look at the full address the email came from. It’s a Gmail account or a made-up name like zellepay-business.net, not the payment company.
Your banking app shows nothing
A real Zelle payment shows up inside your own bank’s app. If it isn’t there, there is no payment, whatever the email says.
The buyer never saw the item
They agree without haggling, can’t come themselves, and keep pushing you to deal with the “upgrade” today.
Where Danger Stamp steps in
Open the Marketplace chat on Facebook or Messenger in Chrome on your computer and Danger Stamp reads the conversation: a buyer pushing a payment that needs your money first gets the chat stamped. The fake Zelle or PayPal email gets a stamp too when you open it in Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo or another webmail.
How Danger Stamp did in testing
- Examples of this scam caught88 of 89
- Normal look-alikes left alone113 of 113
- Caught by the free version, no AI1 of 89
2 real scams of this kind, collected from the web, were stamped in our real-world test rounds.
From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.
Sent the fee or shared a code?
Move fast. Your bank has the best chance of stopping a transfer in the first hours.
What did you give them?
I sent money
- Step 1Do this firstCall your bank or payment app now. Ask them to stop or recall the payment.
- Step 2Keep every message, receipt and phone number.
- Step 3Report it: antifraudcentre.ca or 1-888-495-8501 (Canada), reportfraud.ftc.gov (US), and your local police.
- Step 4Anyone offering to get it back for a fee is a second scam.
A code sent to my phone or email
- Step 1Do this firstSign in yourself now. Change the password. Sign out of all devices.
- Step 2A bank code? Call your bank on the number on your card.
- Step 3Never give a code to anyone who calls or messages you.
My card number
- Step 1Do this firstCall your card company now, on the number on the back of your card.
- Step 2Ask them to cancel the card and dispute any charge you don't recognise.
- Step 3Watch your statements, including tiny "test" charges.
Other versions of the same scam
The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.
| What it says | What it really is |
|---|---|
| A deposit for a puppy or an item you haven’t seen | The seller wants a deposit by Zelle or Cash App to “hold” a puppy, a sold-out item or tickets, then asks for shipping, crate or insurance money. |
| A photo of the front and back of your card | A buyer or seller asks for pictures of your bank card to “prove you’re real” or to “send the money”. Those photos are all they need to spend on it. |
| A check for more than your price | The buyer mails a check for thousands more than you asked and wants the extra sent on to their “transport guy”. The check bounces days later. |
| “How many digits is your PIN?” | After a sale, someone asks about your PIN or a code your bank texted. They are trying to get into your account, not pay you. |
Related scams
Questions
Does Zelle have business accounts that hold payments?
Some banks let businesses receive Zelle payments, but none of them hold a payment until the person getting paid sends money. Any email or text asking you to upgrade, verify or raise a limit by paying is fake.
The buyer sent a screenshot showing they paid the upgrade fee. Is that proof?
No. A screenshot is a picture anyone can edit. Only what appears in your own banking app counts.
The buyer still wants the item. Should I ship it or hand it over?
No. They haven’t paid and won’t. Keep the item, block them, and sell it to someone who pays in person or through the platform’s own checkout.
Where do I report a fake Marketplace buyer?
Report their profile on Facebook from the chat, forward the fake email to the real company’s abuse address, and report it at reportfraud.ftc.gov (US) or antifraudcentre.ca, 1-888-495-8501 (Canada).
Will Danger Stamp warn me in a Marketplace chat?
Yes, when you read the chat in Chrome on a computer. The Facebook app on your phone isn’t covered, but you can paste the buyer’s messages into the checker below.
Sources
This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings:
- BBB Scam Alert: Crafty scam targeting Facebook Marketplace sellers (June 24, 2022, updated July 12, 2024)