From thank-you card to account takeover
You order something small and cheap online. Inside the box is a glossy card: “Get a FREE $30 gift card” or “Full refund for your honest review!” It asks you to leave a review, then email or message the seller with a screenshot.
When you write, the reply is friendly. To send the reward, they just need your PayPal account, your bank details or your card number. Some ask for a code that has just been texted to you, which is really the code to sign in to your account or approve a payment. Others ask for a small fee to process the gift.
With your login and that code, they can take over your PayPal and send money out of it. Bank or card details let them make charges or send fake “payment received” emails that pull you into a refund trick. Either way, the free gift card never comes.
When a review reward turns into a scam
They want more than your email
A real gift card can be sent to an email address. Anyone asking for your PayPal password, card number or bank login doesn’t need it for a reward.
A code just arrived on your phone
If a code shows up right as they ask you to “verify”, it’s a sign-in or payment code for your own account. Never read it out or type it in for them.
A fee to get a free thing
Shipping, “tax” or a processing charge to receive a gift card is the scam paying itself.
The chat moves off the shop
The card sends you to a Gmail, WhatsApp or Telegram contact instead of the marketplace’s own messages.
How Danger Stamp warns you
If the seller’s reply lands in Gmail, Outlook or another webmail, or in WhatsApp Web or Messenger on your computer, Danger Stamp reads it in Chrome and puts a red warning bar on a message that offers a review reward and then asks for your account, card or bank details.
Hi, thank you for buying our Vortix air fryer on Amazon and for your 5-star review!
We send the $30 gift card through PayPal. Please reply with your PayPal email and the 6-digit code PayPal will text you to confirm.
Please claim your reward within 48 hours. Thank you, After-Sales Team
How Danger Stamp did in testing
- Examples of this scam caught18 of 18
- Normal look-alikes left alone19 of 19
- Caught by the free version, no AI1 of 18
From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.
Already sent your PayPal or bank details?
Change your PayPal password first, then call your bank or card company. Don’t wait to see what happens.
What did you give them?
My password
- Step 1Do this firstChange it now on the real site. Type the address yourself.
- Step 2Used it anywhere else? Change it there too.
- Step 3If it was your email password, change that one first.
- Step 4Turn on two-step sign-in.
A code sent to my phone or email
- Step 1Do this firstSign in yourself now. Change the password. Sign out of all devices.
- Step 2A bank code? Call your bank on the number on your card.
- Step 3Never give a code to anyone who calls or messages you.
My card number
- Step 1Do this firstCall your card company now, on the number on the back of your card.
- Step 2Ask them to cancel the card and dispute any charge you don't recognise.
- Step 3Watch your statements, including tiny "test" charges.
My bank login or account details
- Step 1Do this firstCall your bank now, on the number on your card or statement.
- Step 2Ask them to lock online banking and reset your login.
- Step 3Check for new payees, transfers or changed contact details.
Other versions of the same scam
The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.
| What it says | What it really is |
|---|---|
| The “full refund” card | Instead of a gift card, the card promises your money back. To refund you, the seller asks for your bank login or card number. |
| Pay a little to get the reward | The gift card is “ready”, but first you must cover a small processing charge, by gift card or a payment app. |
Related scams
Questions
Are review-for-gift-card cards in packages legal?
Paying for reviews that must be positive breaks US rules. In 2024 the FTC banned businesses from giving rewards on the condition that a review says something good or bad. Either way, a reward that needs your bank login is not a reward.
I already left the review. Is that a problem?
Leaving the review isn’t what puts you at risk. What matters is what you sent the seller afterwards. If it was only your name, just stop replying.
I gave them my PayPal email and a code. What should I do?
Sign in to PayPal by typing its address yourself, change your password, turn on two-step sign-in, and check for payments or new linked cards you don’t recognise. Then call PayPal using the number on its website.
Should I report the seller?
Yes. Report the listing on the marketplace where you bought, and tell the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov or the Anti-Fraud Centre at antifraudcentre.ca.
Sources
This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings: