What the “points expiring” email is really after
The email names a program you might really belong to: a store card, an airline, a pharmacy, or a phone company. It says a big pile of points is about to vanish, today or at midnight, and offers a gift to “save” them.
The button leads to a copy of a rewards page on an address the company doesn’t own. To claim the gift you pay a few dollars for shipping, which means typing your full card number. Some versions ask for your account password or your Social Security number to “confirm it’s you.” The gift never comes. The card details are the real prize.
A close cousin promises a free health kit, a “MyChart Medicare kit,” or free exercise equipment from your health insurer. Those ask for your Medicare or insurance number, which can be used to bill for care you never got.
How to tell the points email is fake
A countdown on your points
“Expires today,” “final notice,” “at midnight.” Any real expiry date is shown when you sign in to the program yourself, so check it there.
A fee to receive something free
Shipping, handling or a “processing” charge of a few dollars before a gift or kit is sent.
The sender isn’t the company
The name says Rewards or the brand, but the address after the @ is some other website, often a cheap ending like .shop or .top.
It asks for numbers points never need
Your card, your Medicare or insurance number, or your SSN, just to redeem points or get a free kit.
How Danger Stamp handles the points email
Open the email in Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo or another webmail in Chrome on your computer and Danger Stamp checks it before you click. When it sees a fake reward or free-kit offer, it puts a red SCAM stamp on the email. If you click through anyway, it checks the claim page too and locks the card box.
Our records show 9,870 ExtraCare points in your account will expire today.
Redeem them now for FREE Bose noise-cancelling headphones. You only pay $5.99 shipping.
Enter your card to cover shipping and your headphones are on the way.
How Danger Stamp did in testing
- Examples of this scam caught14 of 14
- Caught by the free version, no AI0 of 14
From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.
Paid the fee or typed your details?
A small fee still means your full card is out there. Call today.
What did you give them?
My card number
- Step 1Do this firstCall your card company now, on the number on the back of your card.
- Step 2Ask them to cancel the card and dispute any charge you don't recognise.
- Step 3Watch your statements, including tiny "test" charges.
My ID, SIN or SSN, or a photo of my ID
- Step 1Do this firstWatch for accounts or credit opened in your name.
- Step 2Canada: ask Equifax and TransUnion for a fraud alert. US: freeze your credit at Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and go to identitytheft.gov.
- Step 3Sent a photo of a passport or licence? Tell the office that issued it.
Other versions of the same scam
The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.
| What it says | What it really is |
|---|---|
| Free Medicare or health kit | A MyChart-branded “Medicare kit” is “reserved for you.” It wants your Medicare number and home address to ship it. |
| Your health insurer’s free equipment | An email in a big insurer’s name says you qualify for free exercise gear. It isn’t from the insurer. |
| Rewards by text message | The same story by SMS, often in a phone company’s name. The FTC warned about these texts in April 2026. |
Related scams
Questions
Do reward points really expire?
Some do, on a schedule written in the program’s terms. You can see the real date by signing in to the program yourself. If the account shows no expiry, the email was lying.
Why ask for only $4.95?
Because people pay small amounts without thinking twice. A shipping fee is just a reason to get your full card number and security code, which can then be used for much bigger charges.
Is the free Medicare kit ever real?
Treat any email that trades a free kit for your Medicare number as a scam. Give that number only to your own doctor, pharmacy or plan, and call your plan on the number on your card if you’re unsure.
I clicked but closed the page before typing anything. What now?
You’re very likely fine. Delete the email and don’t go back. If the page asked you to download something and you did, run a scan and see the steps for something installed.
Where do I report a fake rewards email?
Mark it as phishing or spam in your email, then report it at reportfraud.ftc.gov (US) or antifraudcentre.ca, 1-888-495-8501 (Canada). You can also forward it to the real company’s abuse or fraud address listed on its website.
Sources
This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings:
- FTC: Got a text about expiring reward points? Look closer (April 7, 2026)