Offered half-price car insurance in a DM? It’s likely a ghost broker, and the policy may not exist.

IInstagram×
https://www.instagram.com/direct/t/
Hhartley.insurance.brokersInstagram
Hi, could you quote car insurance for my son? He just passed his test9:41
Hi! The best we found is Aviva, fully comp with a black box, £118 a month. Our FCA number is on our profile.9:42
Aviva will email you a link to pay and sign on their own site. We never take payment by bank transfer.9:42
Message hartley.insurance.brokers
  1. 1Who it's from
  2. 2What it wants from you
  3. 3How it hooks you

Two Instagram chats about car insurance, drawn from real ones. Hover or tap a number to see what that check tells you.

The short answer

Don’t pay. Call the insurer named on the documents, using the number on its own website, and ask if the policy exists in your name. Only ever pay an insurer or a licensed broker directly, by card, never a person by bank transfer or payment app. Already paid? Check your cover and call your bank.

By the Danger Stamp research team · Updated · 3 minute read

How ghost brokers sell fake cover

A “ghost broker” poses as an insurance agent but isn’t licensed to sell insurance or to act for the company they name. They find buyers through Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, Snapchat and WhatsApp, and target people who pay the most for cover: young drivers, first-time buyers and owners of fast cars.

The price is half what you’d pay anywhere else. You send money by bank transfer, Cash App or Zelle, and receive documents with a real insurer’s logo. Sometimes they’re forged. Sometimes the broker buys a real policy using false details, or buys one in your name and cancels it to pocket the refund.

Either way you’re driving without valid insurance and don’t know it. Most people find out after a crash or a traffic stop, when the insurer has no record of them or refuses the claim.

Warning signs of a fake insurance seller

  1. Insurance sold in DMs

    A real insurer doesn’t sell policies through private messages on social media or WhatsApp.

  2. A price nobody else can match

    Half price for a young driver or a performance car is not a deal, it’s the bait.

  3. Pay a person, not a company

    Bank transfer to a personal account, Cash App, Zelle or crypto. Insurers take payment in their own name.

  4. A website that’s brand new

    A “temporary car insurance” site with a copied look, a registration number that belongs to someone else, and a Gmail address for help.

Where Danger Stamp warns you

In Chrome on your computer, Danger Stamp puts a red warning bar on fake insurance websites and fake marketplace pages. In WhatsApp Web, Messenger and Instagram on the computer, it warns on a conversation where someone sells cover for a transfer, and stamps it when the signs are clear. Ads in your feed for this kind of cover get a small mark of their own.

IInstagram×
https://www.instagram.com/direct/t/
Ccheapcover.ukInstagram
Need car insurance? Any car, any age, fully comp from £55 a month 💯 Half what the big insurers charge9:41
how does it work?9:42
Send me a photo of your licence and the first month by bank transfer to my account (J. Wells). I set it up with the insurer and send your certificate in 1 hour9:42
Message cheapcover.uk
The scam from above, the moment Danger Stamp stamps it in Chrome and locks the page under the stamp.

How Danger Stamp did in testing

  • Examples of this scam caught21 of 22
  • Normal look-alikes left alone28 of 28
  • Caught by the free version, no AI1 of 22

From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.

Already bought cover this way?

First find out if you’re insured at all. Don’t drive until you are.

What did you give them?

I sent money

  1. Step 1Do this firstCall your bank or payment app now. Ask them to stop or recall the payment.
  2. Step 2Keep every message, receipt and phone number.
  3. Step 3Report it: antifraudcentre.ca or 1-888-495-8501 (Canada), reportfraud.ftc.gov (US), and your local police.
  4. Step 4Anyone offering to get it back for a fee is a second scam.

Other versions of the same scam

The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.

What it saysWhat it really is
Copy of a temporary car insurance siteA short-term cover website with a look copied from a real one, a made-up registration number and a Gmail contact address.
Fake health marketplace pageA page that poses as the official marketplace and charges a fee to enrol you in a $0 health plan, or asks for every family member’s Social Security number.
“Health subsidy card” adAn ad promising a cash card for groceries if you sign up for a health plan, while saying little about the cover itself.

Related scams

Questions

How do I check if my car insurance policy is real?

Call the insurance company named on your documents, using the number from its own website, not the one the seller gave you. Ask them to confirm the policy number, your name, the car and the dates.

How do I know if an insurance broker is licensed?

In the US, look them up with your state insurance department. In Canada, check with your province’s insurance regulator. A real broker will give you a licence number and won’t mind you checking it.

What happens if I crash with a fake policy?

You may be treated as uninsured, which can mean paying for the damage yourself, fines and losing your licence. That’s why it’s worth checking today rather than after something goes wrong.

Do I have to pay to sign up for a $0 health plan?

No. Enrolling through HealthCare.gov or the official marketplace call centre is free. Anyone charging a fee to sign you up for a free plan, or asking for cash, crypto or your card to keep your cover, is not to be trusted.

Who do I report a ghost broker to?

Your state or provincial insurance regulator, the insurer whose name was used, and the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov or the Anti-Fraud Centre at antifraudcentre.ca.

Sources

This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings:

Offered cheap insurance by message? Paste it here.

Copy the seller’s message or the insurance page text and paste it below to find out if it carries the marks of a ghost broker.

Checked by our server. The text is blanked of card numbers, ID numbers and other people's addresses before it leaves your browser; nothing is stored.