A stranger found a “security hole” on your site? It’s usually a beg bounty. Don’t pay.

MInbox (3) – Gmail×
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox
✎ ComposeInbox 3StarredSnoozedSent
Your SSL certificate has been renewed
SSquarespace <no-reply@squarespace.com>to me10:42 AM

Hi Brightleaf Bakery,

As part of our regular checks, we renewed the security certificate for brightleafbakery.co.uk. Your site stays secure, with no action needed from you.

Questions? Visit the Help Center in your Squarespace account.

  1. 1Who sent it
  2. 2What it wants from you
  3. 3How it hooks you

Two emails about a small bakery's website, drawn from real ones. Hover or tap a number to see what that check tells you.

The short answer

Don’t pay, don’t promise a reward and don’t open files they send. Pass the email to whoever looks after your website or email, and let them judge the finding. Most of these come from free scanning tools and aren’t worth money. Paid them or are they now threatening you? Start here.

By the Danger Stamp research team · Updated · 3 minute read

How a beg-bounty email is put together

Someone runs a free scanner over thousands of websites and pastes whatever it reports into a template. Typical “findings” are a missing SPF or DMARC email record, a page that could be framed by another site (called clickjacking), or a missing security header. The email calls it critical and asks what your bug bounty pays, or offers to fix it for a fee.

Small businesses are the target, especially ones that have never heard the term bug bounty. Sophos found these senders asking for roughly $150 to $2,000 per issue. It sits in a grey area: some senders are just hopeful, while others edge toward extortion once they sense you’re worried.

How to recognise a beg bounty

  1. It leads with money

    “What reward do you pay?” comes before any real details of the problem.

  2. The flaw is about email records or headers

    DMARC, SPF, clickjacking or “X-Frame-Options” are the usual list from free online checkers.

  3. A free webmail sender

    A Gmail or Outlook address with “hacker,” “security” or “researcher” in it, not a security firm.

  4. Details held back until you agree

    “I will share the full report after we agree on the reward.”

  5. Follow-ups that turn harsher

    No answer? The next email raises the price or the tone. Sophos saw one demand climb from $500 to $5,000.

What Danger Stamp shows on the email

When you open a message like this in webmail in Chrome on your computer, Danger Stamp puts a BEG BOUNTY warning bar across the top of the email. It isn’t a full stamp, because some of these senders aren’t criminals, but it tells you what kind of email it is before you decide to answer.

MInbox (3) – Gmail×
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox
✎ ComposeInbox 3StarredSnoozedSent
Security vulnerability found on your website
RRahul <rahul.sec.research07@gmail.com>to me10:42 AM

Hi Team, I am an independent security researcher and I found a vulnerability on your website brightleafbakery.co.uk. Your domain has no DMARC record, so anyone can send email that looks like it comes from you and phish your customers.

I have a proof of concept ready. Kindly let me know if you have a bug bounty program and what reward you will give for this finding, then I will share the full report with steps to fix.

Regards, Rahul, Security Researcher

The scam from above, the moment Danger Stamp drops its warning bar across it in Chrome.

How Danger Stamp did in testing

100%
6 of 6 held-back tests caughtExamples never used while building the checks, so the fairest measure.
  • Examples of this scam caught18 of 18
  • Normal look-alikes left alone16 of 16
  • Caught by the free version, no AI1 of 18

From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.

Paid them or replied?

Payment rarely ends it. Expect a second “finding” and a bigger number.

What did you give them?

I sent money

  1. Step 1Do this firstCall your bank or payment app now. Ask them to stop or recall the payment.
  2. Step 2Keep every message, receipt and phone number.
  3. Step 3Report it: antifraudcentre.ca or 1-888-495-8501 (Canada), reportfraud.ftc.gov (US), and your local police.
  4. Step 4Anyone offering to get it back for a fee is a second scam.

Other versions of the same scam

The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.

What it saysWhat it really is
The paid “fix”No bounty question, just an offer to repair the problem for a fee.
The second, bigger askAfter a first payment or a polite reply, a new “finding” arrives with a higher price.

Related scams

Questions

Is the problem they found real?

Sometimes, in a minor way. A missing DMARC record, for example, is worth fixing, and your email or web host can usually help. It doesn’t mean someone broke in, and it doesn’t mean you owe the sender anything.

Do I have to pay a bounty?

No. A bug bounty is a program a company chooses to set up, with its own rules. If you never set one up, nobody is entitled to a reward for an email they sent you.

Should I reply at all?

You don’t need to. If you want to, a short thank-you that promises nothing is enough. Never agree to a payment by email or let them sign in to fix it.

What if they threaten to publish it?

Stop replying, keep every email, and have your web person fix the issue so there is nothing to publish. Threats for money can be reported to the police and to ic3.gov or antifraudcentre.ca.

Sources

This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings:

Received a “vulnerability report”? Paste it in.

Paste the email below and Danger Stamp will tell you what it notices, so you can decide how seriously to take it.

Checked by our server. The text is blanked of card numbers, ID numbers and other people's addresses before it leaves your browser; nothing is stored.