How these “real asset” investments go wrong
The pitch comes from a glossy website, an emailed brochure, a social media ad or a cold call. It sells something you can picture: a cask of Scotch maturing in a warehouse, cases of fine wine, a plot of land “about to get planning permission”, carbon credits, a parking space in a city car park, gold in a vault, rare coins or a share in a film. It often targets people with savings or a pension lump sum.
The selling point is a fixed return: 6% to 9% a year on a parking space, “up to 12%” on an electric car park, 20% a year for five years on land plots, or interest added daily on a wine fund. Many offer to buy the asset back from you later. Some claim to be watched over by the FCA or CySEC when they aren’t.
Then the trouble starts. The asset is worth a fraction of what you paid, can’t be sold, belongs to someone else or doesn’t exist. When you ask to sell, the broker wants more fees, a buyer “fell through”, or the firm has vanished. Some carbon credit “platforms” let you fund a wallet and only sell back to them.
Questions to ask before buying a cask, plot or credit
Is the return fixed in advance?
A set percentage every year on whisky, wine, land or credits is a sales line. Their real prices go up and down, and some fall a lot.
Who will you sell it to?
If the only buyer is the firm that sold it to you, you can’t check the price, and they decide when, or if, you get paid.
Is the firm on the regulator’s register?
Many of these assets aren’t regulated at all. In the UK, carbon credits aren’t covered by the FCA, so there’s no compensation scheme if it goes wrong.
Did they contact you first?
Cold calls, mailshots and emails from a firm you never heard of are the most common way investment scams start.
How new is the website?
A “long-established” investment house whose web address was registered a few weeks ago is not established.
What Danger Stamp does with these offers
Danger Stamp checks the investment sites you open in Chrome on your computer and stamps fake asset schemes FAKE INVESTMENT. It also checks the brochure email when you open it in Gmail, Outlook or another webmail, and puts a small stamp on matching sponsored posts in your Facebook or Instagram feed.
Dear investor, rare Scotch whisky casks have beaten the stock market for ten years.
A cask costs £8,500 and grows a guaranteed 12% a year. We buy it back at the guaranteed price after 5 years.
Only 4 casks left at this price. Reply today to reserve yours.
How Danger Stamp did in testing
- Examples of this scam caught80 of 90
- Normal look-alikes left alone120 of 122
- Caught by the free version, no AI3 of 90
From our recorded test run of October 24, 2026. No tool catches every scam, and new versions appear every week. How we test.
Bought a cask, a plot or credits already?
Don’t pay any “selling fee” or “release charge”. That’s often the second half of the same scam.
What did you give them?
I sent money
- Step 1Do this firstCall your bank or payment app now. Ask them to stop or recall the payment.
- Step 2Keep every message, receipt and phone number.
- Step 3Report it: antifraudcentre.ca or 1-888-495-8501 (Canada), reportfraud.ftc.gov (US), and your local police.
- Step 4Anyone offering to get it back for a fee is a second scam.
My bank login or account details
- Step 1Do this firstCall your bank now, on the number on your card or statement.
- Step 2Ask them to lock online banking and reset your login.
- Step 3Check for new payees, transfers or changed contact details.
I called them or talked to them
- Step 1Do this firstHang up. Don't call back.
- Step 2Gave them anything on the call? Pick that here too.
- Step 3To reach the real company, use a number you looked up yourself.
My card number
- Step 1Do this firstCall your card company now, on the number on the back of your card.
- Step 2Ask them to cancel the card and dispute any charge you don't recognise.
- Step 3Watch your statements, including tiny "test" charges.
Other versions of the same scam
The same trick turns up with a different story. The signs and the steps above still apply.
| What it says | What it really is |
|---|---|
| Parking spaces with a yearly return | French-language sites sell spaces in car parks “run by” big operators, promising 6% to 14% a year, on addresses a few weeks old. |
| Carbon credit trading platforms | Buy certificates, watch the value climb on the dashboard, and find the only buyer is the platform itself. |
| Land banking | Plots of farmland sold at many times their value, with talk of planning permission that never comes. |
| Wine-named daily interest funds | A site with a wine merchant’s name that is really a daily-interest scheme, with false claims of FCA or CySEC oversight. |
Related scams
Questions
Is whisky cask investment always a scam?
No, real casks are bought and sold. Buyers get hurt when a seller promises a fixed yearly growth figure or an easy resale, charges far above the going price, or never registers the cask in the buyer’s name.
How do I check that I really own the cask or the wine?
Ask the bonded warehouse or wine storage company directly, using contact details you find yourself, to confirm the item is held in your name. Don’t rely on a certificate from the seller.
They say the land will be worth far more after planning permission. Is that likely?
That pitch is the core of land banking. The plots are usually farmland with little real prospect of permission, sold at many times their value, and a field split into tiny plots is very hard to resell.
A firm now offers to sell my cask or credits for me, for a fee. Should I pay?
Be very careful. Calls offering to sell or buy back an asset you already own, for an upfront fee, are a known follow-up scam.
Who should I tell about a cask, wine or land scheme?
UK buyers can report to Report Fraud (the old Action Fraud) and to the FCA; Canadians to antifraudcentre.ca or 1-888-495-8501; Americans to reportfraud.ftc.gov and their state securities regulator.
Sources
This page is based on the scams people report to us, the examples we test Danger Stamp on, and these warnings:
- FCA: Carbon credit trading scams (Last updated January 19, 2026)
- FCA: Over 55s at heightened risk of fraud, says FCA (May 25, 2016)